Topic
YES 
NO 
  • ( 1 )
    NO 
    JP
    The execution of penalties in the judicial system should not be swayed by public outcry but should be carried out quietly as a strict and calm legal procedure. Adding the element of live broadcasting increases the risk of trials and executions being used as a tool of populism. It leads one to imagine whether the state's inclination towards visual reign of terror, beyond its inherent role of monopolizing violence, would not shake the foundations of democracy.
     2  0  26-10-09 10:57  
  • ( 2 )
    NO 
    JP
    The practice of the state live-streaming executions by the death penalty as a spectacle to an unspecified number of people deviates significantly from the humanitarian principles of criminal justice that modern rule-of-law states have established. The purpose of punishment is solely to maintain social order, and stimulating the curiosity of the masses or using it for a publicExample should not the state's violence be justified?
     2  0  26-10-09 11:09  
  • ( 3 )
    YES 
    JP
    It is highly meaningful for society as a whole to share, without concealment, the process by which the state imposes punishment for heinous acts of terrorism. In modern justice systems that tend to lean towards protecting the human rights of individual offenders, deliberately visualizing the resolute will of the state serves as a psychological deterrent to potential criminals. It is an indispensable process for restoring the justice of the law to directly imprint the heavy reality that has been ignored into the eyes of the public.
     1  0  26-10-09 11:19  
  • ( 4 )
    YES 
    JP
    The Secretary of Defense's decision to strengthen deterrence is effective as a strong message to society. I believe that judgment by court-martial has the significance of demonstrating its authority.
     0  0  26-10-09 11:22  
  • ( 5 )
    YES 
    JP
    Considering the weight of suffering that victims and their bereaved families have carried for many years, the consequences faced by perpetrators should not be quietly processed out of public view. Publicly carrying out severe punishments is the minimum atonement to the victims and an opportunity for society as a whole to share in justice.
     0  0  26-10-09 11:22  
  • ( 6 )
    NO 
    JP
    This is extremely inappropriate. The act of leaving it as video footage is ethically unacceptable.
     0  0  26-10-09 11:23  
  • ( 7 )
    NO 
    JP
    The live broadcast of executions will be seen by many children through the internet, and may lead to the re-enactment of violent acts. If a culture of consuming the moment a life is taken as video becomes established, people's sense of the sanctity of life will be numbed, and there is a risk that the ethics of society as a whole will be significantly damaged. From an educational perspective as well, a clear line should be drawn on this method.
     3  0  26-10-09 11:37  
  • ( 8 )
    NO 
    JP
    Broadcasting an execution live just stirs emotions and I can't help but feel it diverts from the essential discussion.
     0  0  26-10-09 11:38  
  • ( 9 )
    NO 
    JP
    Live broadcasts of executions, for example, are outrageous. Presenting the act of taking a human life as entertainment is simply too inhumane.
     0  0  26-10-09 11:41  
  • ( 10 )
    YES 
    JP
    For deterrence, isn't a scapegoat important too?
     0  0  26-10-09 11:45  
  • ( 11 )
    YES 
    JP
    This could be a powerful message to society. By deliberately live-streaming the execution under the special circumstances of a court-martial, we might be able to more realistically convey the gravity of the crime and the strict punishment for it to a wider audience. I would like to see it have an effect as a deterrent.
     0  0  26-10-09 11:46  
  • ( 12 )
    YES 
    JP
    From the perspective of strengthening deterrence, ensuring data-based transparency is important. It is statistically significant that society directly confronting the solemn fact of enforcement will lead to a reduction in the incidence of similar heinous crimes.
     0  0  26-10-09 11:47  
  • ( 13 )
    NO 
    JP
    Live streaming of executions is absolutely unacceptable, regardless of the reason. Presenting the act of taking a life as entertainment would severely degrade society's sense of ethics. Furthermore, exposing a person's death to the public is inherently extremely cruel and shows a lack of consideration for the feelings of the bereaved family. It is tragic that technological advancements lead to such inhumane ideas.
     2  0  26-10-09 11:49  
  • ( 14 )
    NO 
    JP
    I do not believe that acts that take human lives should be presented as entertainment. Even in the name of deterrence to society, it should not be done by trampling on human dignity.
     0  0  26-10-09 11:50  
  • ( 15 )
    NO 
    JP
    A live broadcast of an execution is unacceptable for any reason. It is an act that gravely undermines human dignity and only raises questions about the maturity of society. There are concerns that it could lead to human rights violations.
     2  0  26-10-09 11:51  
  • ( 16 )
    YES 
    JP
    The exercise of state power, especially the gravest decision of carrying out capital punishment, should be conducted in a completely open and public manner. I believe that it is a necessary measure to maintain the credibility of the judiciary in a democratic state for all citizens to directly confront the facts and face squarely the procedures and costs by which the state carries out its sentences.
     0  0  26-10-09 11:52  
  • ( 17 )
    NO 
    JP
    Live-streaming an execution is far too inhumane. Furthermore, even if it's a court-martial, publicly displaying the execution of a person is nothing short of barbaric. The idea that it would serve as a deterrent to society is merely an excuse to trample on human dignity. I am absolutely opposed to it.
     0  0  26-10-09 13:14  
  • ( 18 )
    NO 
    JP
    A live broadcast of an execution, it couldn't possibly be entertainment.
     0  0  26-10-09 13:38  
  • ( 19 )
    NO 
    JP
    I am absolutely opposed to the live broadcast of an execution, for any reason whatsoever. It is an act that tramples on human dignity and amounts to the state exposing excessive violence. I believe this type of footage only brings fear and division to society, deviating from the judicial goals of correction and rehabilitation that should be pursued.
     0  0  26-10-09 14:04  
  • ( 20 )
    NO 
    JP
    The live broadcast of an execution is an act that tramples on human dignity and is out of the question. We should not numb our sense of ethics under the guise of deterrence.
     0  0  26-10-09 14:14  
Vote
Click here!
Voting Booth
 0
YES 
 0
NO 
Result
Overall Result
YES
NO
NaN%
NaN%
Note: The overall rating is calculated based on the difference between empathy/disagreement buttons and the total number of votes for each user comment.
SNS

Get updates on your timeline

Follow us on official SNS for daily updates!

Vote Complete!

You are in the majority.
Overall ratio: 50%.

Log in and leave a comment?

Vote Complete!

You are in the majority.
Overall ratio: 50%.

Log in and leave a comment?